| DAT | MOTSTÅNDARE | RESULTAT | MÅLGÖRARE | pl | |
| 1 sep | H | PRESTON NORTH END | 0-0 |
||
| 5 | b | Liverpool | 1-2 |
Hilsdon | |
| 7 | b | Preston North End | 0-6 |
||
| 12 | H | BURY | 4-1 | Warren, Humphreys, Hilsdon, Bridgeman | |
| 19 | b | Sheffield United | 3-1 | Brawn, Humphreys, Hilsdon | |
| 21 | H | NOTTINGHAM FOREST | 2-1 | Hilsdon, Windridge | |
| 26 | H | ASTON VILLA | 0-2 |
||
| 3 okt | b | Nottingham Forest | 1-2 |
Humphreys | |
| 10 | H | SUNDERLAND | 2-0 | Rouse, WIndridge | |
| 17 | H | THE WEDNESDAY | 2-2 |
Rouse 2 | |
| 24 | b | Blackburn Rovers | 0-2 |
||
| 31 | H | BRADFORD CITY | 1-1 |
Hilsdon | |
| 7 nov | b | Manchester United | 1-0 | Hilsdon str | |
| 14 | H | Everton | 3-3 |
Hilsdon 3 | |
| 21 | b | Leicester Fosse | 2-5 |
Warren, Hilsdon | |
| 28 | H | WOOLWICH ARSENAL | 1-2 |
Hilsdon | |
| 5 dec | b | Notts County | 0-3 |
||
| 12 | H | NEWCASTLE UNITED | 1-2 |
Humphreys | |
| 19 | b | Bristol City | 0-1 |
||
| 25 | b | Manchester City | 2-1 | Brawn, Rouse | |
| 26 | H | MANCHESTER CITY | 1-2 |
Humphreys | |
| 1909 1 jan |
b | Middlesbrough | 4-1 | Hilsdon3, Windridge | |
| 23 | H | SHEFFIELD UNITED | 1-1 |
Brawn | |
| 30 | b | Aston Villa | 0-0 |
||
| 13 feb | b | Sunderland | 2-1 | Birnie, Douglas | |
| 27 | H | BLACKBURN ROVERS | 1-1 |
Hilsdon str | |
| 13 mars | H | MANCHESTER UNITED | 1-1 |
Bridgeman | |
| 20 | b | Everton | 2-3 |
Hilsdon str, Windridge | |
| 22 | b | The Wednesday | 1-5 |
Windridge | |
| 31 | b | Bury | 1-2 |
Hilsdon | |
| 3 apr | b | Woolwich Arsenal | 0-0 |
||
| 9 | H | MIDDLESBROUGH | 3-0 | Humphreys, Hilsdon 2 | |
| 10 | H | NOTTS COUNTY | 3-2 | Warren, Humphreys, Hilsdon str | |
| 17 | b | Newcastle United | 3-1 | Humphreys, Hilsdon 2 | |
| 20 | b | Bradford City | 0-3 |
||
| 26 | H | BRISTOL CITY | 3-1 | Humphreys, Hilsdon 2 | |
| 29 | H | LEICESTER FOSSE | 1-0 | Bridgeman |