| DAT | MOTSTÅNDARE | RESULTAT | MÅLGÖRARE | pl | |
| 24 aug | b | Tottenham | 1-1 |
Greaves | |
| 28 | H | MANCHESTER CITY | 2-3 |
Greaves, Lewis | |
| 31 | H | BIRMINGHAM | 5-1 | Brabrook, ALlen, Greaves 2, Lewis | |
| 4 sep | b | Manchester City | 2-5 |
Brabrook, Lewis | |
| 7 | b | Everton | 0-3 |
||
| 11 | H | WEST BROMWICH | 2-2 |
Tindall 2 | |
| 14 | b | Newcastle | 3-1 | Tindall 2, Block | |
| 18 | b | West Bromwich | 1-1 |
Greaves | |
| 21 | H | BURNLEY | 6-1 | Brabrook, Greaves, Tindall, Nicholas 2, Block | |
| 28 | b | Preston | 2-5 |
Tindall, Nicholas | |
| 5 okt | H | SHEFFIELD WEDNESDAY | 1-0 | Tindall | |
| 12 | H | ASTON VILLA | 4-2 | Tindall 2, Nicholas 2 | |
| 19 | b | Wolverhampton | 1-2 |
Nicholas | |
| 26 | H | ARSENAL | 0-0 |
||
| 2 nov | b | Blackpool | 1-2 |
Greaves | |
| 9 | H | LUTON | 1-3 |
Block | |
| 16 | b | Sunderland | 2-2 |
Stubbs, Lewis | |
| 23 | H | LEICESTER | 4-0 | McNichol, Tindall, Lewis 2 | |
| 30 | b | Bolton | 3-3 |
Brabrook, Stubbs, Lewis | |
| 7 dec | H | LEEDS | 2-1 | McNichol, Stubbs | |
| 14 | b | Manchester United | 1-0 | Tindall | |
| 21 | H | TOTTENHAM | 2-4 |
Bellett, McNichol | |
| 25 | H | PORTSMOUTH | 7-4 | Sillett, Tindall, Greaves 4, självmål | |
| 26 | b | Portsmouth | 0-3 |
||
| 28 | b | Birmingham | 3-3 |
Sillett, Brbrook, Greaves | |
| 1958 11 jan |
H | EVERTON | 3-1 | McNichol, Greaves 2 | |
| 18 | H | NEWCASTLE | 2-1 | Greaves, Lewis | |
| 1 feb | b | Burnley | 1-2 |
Allen | |
| 8 | H | PRESTON | 0-2 |
||
| 15 | b | Sheffield Wednesday | 3-2 | Greaves 3 | |
| 22 | b | Aston Villa | 3-1 | Mortimore, Brabrook, Tindall | |
| 8 mars | b | Arsenal | 4-5 |
Tindall, Greaves 2, Block | |
| 11 | H | WOLVERHAMPTON | 1-2 |
Greaves | |
| 15 | H | BLACKPOOL | 1-4 |
Greaves | |
| 22 | b | Leicester | 2-3 |
Sillett, Tindall | |
| 29 | H | SUNDERLAND | 0-0 |
||
| 4 apr | H | NOTTINGHAM | 0-0 |
||
| 5 | b | Luton | 2-0 | Brabrook, Tindall | |
| 7 | b | Nottingham | 1-1 |
Stubbs | |
| 12 | H | BOLTON | 2-2 |
Sillett str, Brabrook | |
| 19 | b | Leeds | 0-0 |
||
| 26 | H | MANCHESTER UNITED | 2-1 | Cliss, Allen | 11 |